When a friend asked me what he should do pertaining to his situation… my tendency is to give advice.
I think we (the whole lot of people reading this blog anyway, I think) have been brought up to give help by giving advice. This may be the most irresponsible thing to really do.
I talked to a few primary school children from where I used to work, they told me that they would not listen to adults advice… or at least one of them said that. These guys are primary five young boys, and street smart they are.
It comes down to the story of this father telling his son not to be afraid of the bully and just standing up to him would be enough for the bully to turn all cowardly. What happened was, this boy got a sound beating of his life… and was afraid to go for recess since then. Was the boy obedient? Yes. Did he take his father’s advice? Yes. Did he do the ‘right thing’? Yes. Did he get beaten up and then became traumatise about the situation? Yes.
I believe that as adults (or I hope we are cognitively and emotionally mature), we would and should be careful about giving advice. Maybe I don’t know enough about the situation. Maybe I have never been in that situation before. Maybe I am not capable of empathizing the situation… maybe I am not getting some details right.
And maybe I shouldn’t be giving this advice.